Example 7 of 8 · real output · sbomlyze v0.8.0

One image, three formats

The same nginx image as Syft JSON, CycloneDX and SPDX diffs to nothing in every pairing, while their compliance scores differ: NTIA 57, 71 and 71.

containerdeb Cross-format diffCompliance scoringFormat conversion

What happened

Teams end up with SBOMs in more than one format. Diffed naively, the same image looks different in each: CycloneDX lists files as components, SPDX folds license names into LicenseRef- ids, and only some formats record file ownership or the OS. sbomlyze reads each one into the same model, so the three versions of one scan compare as identical.

They are not equally complete, though. The same scan scores differently against the NTIA, CISA and BSI minimum elements depending on the output format: Syft JSON has no document timestamp, which costs it the NTIA timestamp check. Other checks differ too: the SPDX carries a supplier for 74 of the 150 packages, the Syft JSON and CycloneDX for 149. The per-check results are in the full output.

What this does not prove. A score measures which minimum elements the document carries, not whether the data in them is right.

Inputs

Generated once with Syft 1.56.0, linux/amd64, and kept unchanged in testdata/showcase in the repository. Every sbomlyze release re-runs the commands below on these exact files.

nginx:1.28.0, built 8 Dec 2025
syft scan registry:index.docker.io/library/nginx@sha256:3b03dfd827515a07ccf4946000f0bbdd2a4fb6aca7499249fcb6b1f9726823d6 -o syft-json=nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json
syft scan registry:index.docker.io/library/nginx@sha256:3b03dfd827515a07ccf4946000f0bbdd2a4fb6aca7499249fcb6b1f9726823d6 -o cyclonedx-json=nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json
syft scan registry:index.docker.io/library/nginx@sha256:3b03dfd827515a07ccf4946000f0bbdd2a4fb6aca7499249fcb6b1f9726823d6 -o spdx-json=nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json
nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json 24e6c51001f4…   nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json 6c0464290725…   nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json 9dee7703cc4d…  

Output

Syft JSON vs CycloneDX

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json · exit 0
Key Findings:
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 0 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found
Full text output (31 lines)
SBOM Comparison
======================================================================
                        Before                                After
File:                   nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json            nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json
File Size:              4 MB                                  1 MB
Format:                 Syft JSON 16.1.12                     CycloneDX 1.7
Generator:              syft 1.56.0                           syft 1.56.0
OS:                     Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12  Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12
Source:                 index.docker.io/library/nginx         index.docker.io/library/nginx
Source Type:            image                                 container
Total Components:       150                                   150
  deb:                  149                                   149             
  maven:                1                                     1               
Data Quality:
  PURL Coverage:        100.0%                                100.0%
  License Coverage:     99.3%                                 99.3%
  Hash Coverage:        0.7%                                  0.0%
  CPE Coverage:         100.0%                                100.0%
======================================================================

Scan Context:
  Schema:                 16.1.12                 (none)
  Scan Scope:             squashed                (none)

Key Findings:
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 0 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found

text (2 KB)

Syft JSON vs SPDX

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json · exit 0
Key Findings:
  💻 OS not recorded in the after SBOM (before: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12)
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 1 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found
Full text output (32 lines)
SBOM Comparison
======================================================================
                        Before                                After
File:                   nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json            nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json
File Size:              4 MB                                  3 MB
Format:                 Syft JSON 16.1.12                     SPDX 2.3
Generator:              syft 1.56.0                           syft 1.56.0
OS:                     Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12  (none)
Source:                 index.docker.io/library/nginx         index.docker.io/library/nginx
Source Type:            image                                 image
Total Components:       150                                   150
  deb:                  149                                   149             
  maven:                1                                     1               
Data Quality:
  PURL Coverage:        100.0%                                100.0%
  License Coverage:     99.3%                                 99.3%
  Hash Coverage:        0.7%                                  0.7%
  CPE Coverage:         100.0%                                100.0%
======================================================================

Scan Context:
  Schema:                 16.1.12                 (none)
  Scan Scope:             squashed                (none)

Key Findings:
  💻 OS not recorded in the after SBOM (before: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12)
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 1 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found

text (2 KB)

CycloneDX vs SPDX

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json · exit 0
Key Findings:
  💻 OS not recorded in the after SBOM (before: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12)
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 0 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found
Full text output (28 lines)
SBOM Comparison
======================================================================
                        Before                                After
File:                   nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json             nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json
File Size:              1 MB                                  3 MB
Format:                 CycloneDX 1.7                         SPDX 2.3
Generator:              syft 1.56.0                           syft 1.56.0
OS:                     Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12  (none)
Source:                 index.docker.io/library/nginx         index.docker.io/library/nginx
Source Type:            container                             image
Total Components:       150                                   150
  deb:                  149                                   149             
  maven:                1                                     1               
Data Quality:
  PURL Coverage:        100.0%                                100.0%
  License Coverage:     99.3%                                 99.3%
  Hash Coverage:        0.0%                                  0.7%
  CPE Coverage:         100.0%                                100.0%
======================================================================

Key Findings:
  💻 OS not recorded in the after SBOM (before: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12)
  🔄 0 version changes among 150 shared packages — no actual upgrades
  🙈 Integrity drift checked only 0 of 150 same-version packages; the rest carry no comparable digest
  ✅ Core system packages stable: deb (149) unchanged
No differences found

text (2 KB)

Compliance of the Syft JSON

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.syft.json --compliance · exit 0
🟠 NTIA Compliance   Score: 57/100 (4/7 checks passed)
🔴 CISA Compliance   Score: 40/100 (4/10 checks passed)
🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance   Score: 33/100 (3/9 checks passed)
Full text output (111 lines)
Scan Context:
  Tool:               syft 1.56.0
  Schema:             16.1.12
  Scan Scope:         squashed
  Source Type:        image
  Source:             index.docker.io/library/nginx

Key Findings:
  💻 OS/Distro: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm)
  📦 Dominated by deb: 149 of 150 packages (99.3%)
  📂 3,715 files tracked on filesystem
  🔗 Relationships: 3,543 containment + 400 dependency
  📁 Top directories: /var/lib/dpkg (149), /usr/share/java (1)
  📜 License profile: 22% permissive, 57% copyleft, 20% unknown
  ⚠️ Low hash coverage: 0.7% (149 of 150 missing)
  🔍 Top catalogers: dpkg-db-cataloger (149), java-archive-cataloger (1)

📦 SBOM Statistics
==================

Total Components: 150

By Package Type:
  deb          149
  maven        1

Licenses:
  With license:    149
  Without license: 1

  Top Licenses:
    GPL-2.0-only                   67
    GPL-2.0-or-later               59
    BSD-3-Clause                   56
    GPL-3.0-only                   38
    GPL-3.0-or-later               37
    public-domain                  30
    LGPL-2.1-only                  27
    BSD-2-Clause                   26
    LGPL-2.0-only                  23
    LGPL-2.1-or-later              21
    ... and 161 more

Integrity:
  With hashes:    1
  Without hashes: 149

Dependencies:
  Components with deps: 140
  Total dep relations:  400


🟠 NTIA Compliance
========================================
Score: 57/100 (4/7 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Supplier Name                  149/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires the name of the entity that creates and identifies each component
  ✅ Other Unique Identifiers       All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires dependency relationships covering at least all top-level dependencies
  ✅ SBOM Author                    syft
  ❌ SBOM Timestamp                 missing
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires the date and time of SBOM data assembly

🔴 CISA Compliance
========================================
Score: 40/100 (4/10 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Software Producer              149/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires identifying the producer of each component
  ✅ Software Identifiers           All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires a dependency graph covering components and their dependencies
  ❌ License Information            149/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds license data per component (an explicit 'unknown' is permitted)
  ❌ Component Hash                 1/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds a cryptographic hash per component where the artifact is available
  ✅ Tool Name                      syft
  ❌ SBOM Author                    missing
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires the person or organization that created the SBOM (distinct from the tool)
  ❌ SBOM Timestamp                 missing
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires an ISO 8601 timestamp of SBOM creation

🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance
========================================
Score: 33/100 (3/9 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Component Creator              149/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires the creator of each component (email or URL contact)
  ✅ Unique Identifiers             All 150 components
  ❌ Distribution Licences          48/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires distribution licences, expressed as SPDX identifiers per §6.1
  ❌ SHA-512 Hash                   0/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires a SHA-512 checksum of each deployable component
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires per-component dependency enumeration with completeness indication
  ❌ SBOM Creator Contact           missing
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.1 requires the email address (or URL) of the SBOM creator — a tool name does not qualify
  ❌ SBOM Timestamp                 missing
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.1 requires the date/time of SBOM compilation

📊 Overall Compliance Score: 43/100

text (5 KB) · json (16 KB)

Compliance of the CycloneDX

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.cdx.json --compliance · exit 0
🟡 NTIA Compliance   Score: 71/100 (5/7 checks passed)
🟠 CISA Compliance   Score: 50/100 (5/10 checks passed)
🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance   Score: 44/100 (4/9 checks passed)
Full text output (105 lines)
Scan Context:
  Tool:               syft 1.56.0
  Source Type:        container
  Source:             index.docker.io/library/nginx

Key Findings:
  💻 OS/Distro: Debian GNU/Linux 12 (bookworm) 12.12
  📦 Dominated by deb: 149 of 150 packages (99.3%)
  📁 Top directories: /var/lib/dpkg (149), /usr/share/java (1)
  📜 License profile: 22% permissive, 57% copyleft, 20% unknown
  ⚠️ Low hash coverage: 0.0% (150 of 150 missing)

📦 SBOM Statistics
==================

Total Components: 3866

By Package Type:
  deb          149
  file         3715
  maven        1
  operating-system 1

Licenses:
  With license:    149
  Without license: 3717

  Top Licenses:
    GPL-2.0-only                   66
    GPL-2.0-or-later               59
    BSD-3-Clause                   53
    GPL-3.0-only                   37
    GPL-3.0-or-later               37
    public-domain                  30
    LGPL-2.1-only                  27
    LGPL-2.0-only                  23
    BSD-2-Clause                   21
    LGPL-2.1-or-later              21
    ... and 161 more

Integrity:
  With hashes:    3715
  Without hashes: 151

Dependencies:
  Components with deps: 140
  Total dep relations:  400


🟡 NTIA Compliance
========================================
Score: 71/100 (5/7 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Supplier Name                  149/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires the name of the entity that creates and identifies each component
  ✅ Other Unique Identifiers       All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires dependency relationships covering at least all top-level dependencies
  ✅ SBOM Author                    syft
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-08T20:24:45-05:00

🟠 CISA Compliance
========================================
Score: 50/100 (5/10 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Software Producer              149/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires identifying the producer of each component
  ✅ Software Identifiers           All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires a dependency graph covering components and their dependencies
  ❌ License Information            149/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds license data per component (an explicit 'unknown' is permitted)
  ❌ Component Hash                 0/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds a cryptographic hash per component where the artifact is available
  ✅ Tool Name                      syft
  ❌ SBOM Author                    missing
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires the person or organization that created the SBOM (distinct from the tool)
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-08T20:24:45-05:00

🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance
========================================
Score: 44/100 (4/9 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Component Creator              149/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires the creator of each component (email or URL contact)
  ✅ Unique Identifiers             All 150 components
  ❌ Distribution Licences          48/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires distribution licences, expressed as SPDX identifiers per §6.1
  ❌ SHA-512 Hash                   0/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires a SHA-512 checksum of each deployable component
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires per-component dependency enumeration with completeness indication
  ❌ SBOM Creator Contact           missing
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.1 requires the email address (or URL) of the SBOM creator — a tool name does not qualify
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-08T20:24:45-05:00

📊 Overall Compliance Score: 55/100

text (5 KB) · json (15 KB)

Compliance of the SPDX

$ sbomlyze nginx-1.28.0-dec.spdx.json --compliance · exit 0
🟡 NTIA Compliance   Score: 71/100 (5/7 checks passed)
🟠 CISA Compliance   Score: 60/100 (6/10 checks passed)
🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance   Score: 44/100 (4/9 checks passed)
Full text output (101 lines)
Scan Context:
  Tool:               syft 1.56.0
  Source Type:        image
  Source:             index.docker.io/library/nginx

Key Findings:
  📦 Dominated by deb: 149 of 150 packages (99.3%)
  📁 Top directories: /var/lib/dpkg (149), /usr/share/java (1)
  📜 License profile: 22% permissive, 57% copyleft, 20% unknown
  ⚠️ Low hash coverage: 0.7% (149 of 150 missing)

📦 SBOM Statistics
==================

Total Components: 150

By Package Type:
  deb          149
  maven        1

Licenses:
  With license:    149
  Without license: 1

  Top Licenses:
    BSD-3-Clause AND BSD-4-Clause AND LicenseRef-BSLA AND GPL-2.0-only AND GPL-2.0-or-later AND GPL-3.0-only AND GPL-3.0-or-later AND LicenseRef-LGPL AND LGPL-2.0-only AND LGPL-2.0-or-later AND LGPL-2.1-only AND LGPL-2.1-or-later AND LGPL-3.0-only AND LGPL-3.0-or-later AND MIT AND LicenseRef-public-domain 8
    BSD-2-Clause                   6
    Apache-2.0 AND Apache-2.0 AND BSD-3-Clause AND LicenseRef-GPL AND GPL-2.0-only AND GPL-2.0-or-later AND ISC AND Kazlib AND LGPL-2.0-only AND Latex2e 5
    BSD-3-Clause AND LicenseRef-BSD-tcp-wrappers AND Beerware AND LicenseRef-GPL AND GPL-2.0-only AND GPL-2.0-or-later AND GPL-3.0-only AND GPL-3.0-or-later AND LGPL-2.0-only AND LGPL-2.0-or-later AND LicenseRef-public-domain 4
    LicenseRef-936728f4181718f42951b881c1e8f1386bf6b2723c4fbc533c374d6f42c71816 4
    BSD-3-Clause AND LicenseRef-MIT-X11 AND X11 3
    GPL-2.0-only AND GPL-2.0-or-later 3
    LicenseRef-da8191658b3452ce9caf31638ba61dab31a38c619fa39df119812e050f592fd3 3
    MIT                            3
    Apache-2.0                     2
    ... and 92 more

Integrity:
  With hashes:    1
  Without hashes: 149

Dependencies:
  Components with deps: 140
  Total dep relations:  400


🟡 NTIA Compliance
========================================
Score: 71/100 (5/7 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Supplier Name                  74/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires the name of the entity that creates and identifies each component
  ✅ Other Unique Identifiers       All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     NTIA Minimum Elements (2021) requires dependency relationships covering at least all top-level dependencies
  ✅ SBOM Author                    Anchore, Inc
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-09T01:24:49Z

🟠 CISA Compliance
========================================
Score: 60/100 (6/10 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Software Producer              74/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires identifying the producer of each component
  ✅ Software Identifiers           All 150 components
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements requires a dependency graph covering components and their dependencies
  ❌ License Information            149/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds license data per component (an explicit 'unknown' is permitted)
  ❌ Component Hash                 1/150 components
     CISA 2025 Minimum Elements adds a cryptographic hash per component where the artifact is available
  ✅ Tool Name                      syft
  ✅ SBOM Author                    Anchore, Inc
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-09T01:24:49Z

🔴 BSI-TR-03183 Compliance
========================================
Score: 44/100 (4/9 checks passed)

  ✅ Component Name                 All 150 components
  ✅ Component Version              All 150 components
  ❌ Component Creator              74/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires the creator of each component (email or URL contact)
  ✅ Unique Identifiers             All 150 components
  ❌ Distribution Licences          149/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires distribution licences, expressed as SPDX identifiers per §6.1
  ❌ SHA-512 Hash                   0/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires a SHA-512 checksum of each deployable component
  ❌ Dependency Relationship        148/150 components
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.2 requires per-component dependency enumeration with completeness indication
  ❌ SBOM Creator Contact           missing
     BSI TR-03183-2 §5.2.1 requires the email address (or URL) of the SBOM creator — a tool name does not qualify
  ✅ SBOM Timestamp                 2026-11-09T01:24:49Z

📊 Overall Compliance Score: 58/100

text (5 KB) · json (21 KB)

Checked at every release

The site is not updated if any of these stop holding for a new sbomlyze release.

RunCheck
syft-vs-cdxtext contains “No differences found”
syft-vs-spdxtext contains “No differences found”
cdx-vs-spdxtext contains “No differences found”
compliance-syftcompliance.ntia.score = 57
compliance-cdxcompliance.ntia.score = 71
compliance-spdxcompliance.ntia.score = 71
compliance-syftcompliance.ntia.checks[id=ntia-timestamp].passed = false
compliance-cdxcompliance.ntia.checks[id=ntia-timestamp].passed = true
compliance-syftcompliance.ntia.checks[id=ntia-supplier].details = "149/150 components"
compliance-cdxcompliance.ntia.checks[id=ntia-supplier].details = "149/150 components"
compliance-spdxcompliance.ntia.checks[id=ntia-supplier].details = "74/150 components"

Sources

← Transitive churn in a point release All examples A license change in a minor release →